Skip to content

Claim · Historical claim

The Prophet appointed no successor, and the community unanimously chose Abu Bakr.

Verdict: Partly supported9th–10th c. (the hadith collections and creeds)

Who claims

Sunni Islam· Islam

About

Shia Islam· Islam

Claim

The Prophet appointed no successor, and the community unanimously chose Abu Bakr. The Shia deny both.

Where it is claimed

2

What the sources show

Verdict: Partly supported

That no written designation was left agrees with reports accepted by both sides. But “unanimously” is not borne out by the sources: the Sunni collections themselves report that the choice was made in haste, without the Prophet's family, and that Ali withheld his pledge for half a year.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

5
  • Text

    الأحكام, 7218Bukhari

    al-Bukhārī 7218

    Umar: “If I appoint a successor, Abu Bakr did so; if I leave it, the Messenger of God did so.”

  • Text

    العلم, 114Bukhari

    al-Bukhārī 114

    Before his death the Prophet asked for writing materials to write that after which the community would not go astray; it was not written.

  • Text

    الحدود, رجم الحبلى من الزنا إذا أحصنتBukhari

    al-Bukhārī 6830

    Umar on the Saqifa: the pledge to Abu Bakr was a “sudden affair” (falta); Ali, al-Zubayr and those with them stayed away.

  • Text

    المغازي, 4240Bukhari

    al-Bukhārī 4240

    Ali did not pledge allegiance to Abu Bakr for six months, while Fatima was alive.

  • Scholarship

    W. Madelung, The Succession to Muḥammad (1997)not in the library

    An analysis of the early reports on the Saqifa and on the position of the clan of Hashim.

The Prophet appointed no successor, and the community unanimously chose Abu Bakr. · Versemora