Skip to content

Claim · Historical claim

At Ghadir Khumm the Prophet appointed Ali as his successor.

Verdict: A matter of interpretation8th–10th c.

Who claims

Shia Islam· Islam

About

Sunni Islam· Islam

Claim

At Ghadir Khumm the Prophet appointed Ali as his successor. The Sunni accept the words themselves but see no appointment in them.

Where it is claimed

2
  • al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, Book of the Proof (Kitab al-Hujja), c. 900–941 (not in the library)

  • al-Mufid, Kitab al-Irshad (c. 1000; not in the library)

What the sources show

Verdict: A matter of interpretation

The gathering at Ghadir Khumm and the words themselves are transmitted by both traditions, so the event is not in dispute. The dispute is over the meaning: whether mawlā here means a “master” owed obedience or a “close friend”, and whether this was an appointment. The sources do not settle it: it is a question of interpretation.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

5
  • Text

    كتاب المناقب عن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم, 3713Tirmidhi

    al-Tirmidhī 3713

    A Sunni collection transmits the Prophet's words “Whoever's mawlā I am, Ali is his mawlā” and calls the hadith sound.

  • Text

    فضائل الصحابة رضي الله عنهم, 2408Muslim

    Muslim 2408

    The Prophet's address “at a water called Khumm”: he leaves the community “two weighty things”, the Book of God and his household.

  • Text

    Quran 5:67

    “O Messenger, convey what has been sent down to you…” — Shia commentators refer the verse to Ghadir, Sunni ones to the preaching in general.

  • Text

    الإيمان, 45Bukhari

    al-Bukhārī 45

    Umar: the verse “Today I have perfected your religion” (5:3) came down on the day of Arafat, that is, before Ghadir; Shia tradition connects it with Ghadir.

  • Scholarship

    W. Madelung, The Succession to Muḥammad (1997); Encyclopaedia of Islam, “Ghadīr Khumm”not in the library

    The word mawlā means both “master, patron” and “one who is close, ally, client”.