Claim · Corrupted text
The Protestants (Luther) threw seven books out of the Bible because they contradicted their teaching.
Who claims
Catholicism· Christianity
About
Protestantism· Christianity
Where it is claimed
1Catholic apologetics of the 19th–20th c.not in the library
What the sources show
The Protestants did exclude these books from the canon, but following the Hebrew canon and Jerome, not only for doctrine's sake; and for two and a half centuries they printed them in their Bibles as a separate section. “Threw them out of the Bible” describes the 19th century more than Luther.
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
Evidence
3Text
Article 6. Of the Sufficiency of the holy Scriptures for salvationThirty-nine Articles
Thirty-nine Articles (1571), art. 6
The Church of England reads these books “for example of life and instruction of manners” but does not apply them to establish doctrine — a demotion, not removal.
Text
2 Macc 12:43KJV
King James Bible (1611) with the Apocrypha
Protestant Bibles of the 16th–17th c. (Luther 1534, the King James Bible 1611) printed these books as a separate section, “Apocrypha”; they were widely dropped from printing only in the 19th c. (British and Foreign Bible Society, 1826).
Text
1.3Westminster Confession
The Reformed confession states outright that these books are “not of divine inspiration” and “no part of the Canon”.