Skip to content

Claim · Historical claim

The disciples stole Jesus' body by night, which is why the tomb was empty.

Verdict: Unverifiablelate 1st c. (attested in Matthew)

Who claims

Second Temple Judaism· Judaism

About

Christianity· as a whole

Where it is claimed

2
  • Matt 28:13SBLGNT

    Matthew 28:13–15 (reports this explanation)

  • Justin, Dialogue with Trypho 108; Tertullian, De spectaculis 30; later Toledot Yeshunot in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Unverifiable

These are rival explanations of one report: Christians — resurrection; their opponents — theft of the body. Both go beyond what historical sources can establish; it is only known that the dispute existed already in the 1st century.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

2
  • Internal evidence

    Matt 28:15SBLGNT

    Matthew 28:15

    “This story has been spread among the Jews to this day” — the explanation was current already in the 1st c.

  • Scholarship

    Historical scholarship on the burial and the empty tomb (e.g. D. Allison, Resurrecting Jesus, 2005)not in the library

    The empty tomb is attested only by Christian texts; the guard story only by Matthew; neither theft nor resurrection can be established by historical means.

The disciples stole Jesus' body by night, which is why the tomb was empty. · Versemora