Skip to content

Contradiction · An older source

Book 1, 2

Whose text

Gnosticism· Christianity

What is said

The visible world was made not by the highest God but by a lower creator ignorant of him.

Where it is said

Book 1, 2Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Books I-V (tr. A. Roberts & W. H. Rambaut, ANF 1)

Irenaeus, Against Heresies I.5.2 (an account of the Valentinian teaching)

What contradicts it

3
  • Gen 1:31WLC· 6th–5th c. BCE (scholarly dating)

    Genesis 1:31

    “And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good” — the creator is God, and the creation is good.

  • 29aTimaeus· c. 360 BCE

    In Plato the constructor of the cosmos is good and the cosmos the fairest of things that have come to be.

  • John 1:3· c. 90–110

    “All things were made through him” — creation is the work of the Word of the highest God.

How the tradition answers

The Gnostic teachers read Genesis as the story of a lower creator and the words “I am God, and there is no other” as his error. The schools differed: according to Ptolemy (Letter to Flora) the creator is neither evil nor perfect but just, standing midway between the highest God and the adversary.

Note

The teaching is known here from an opponent's account; the Gnostics' own texts are not in the library.
The visible world was made not by the highest God but by a lower creator ignorant of him. · Versemora