Skip to content

Contradiction · The tradition's own texts

Avot, 1

Whose text

Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism

What is said

The sages may enact new ordinances and “make a fence around the Torah”; the tradition they hand down binds equally with the written Law.

Where it is said

Avot, 1Mishnah (Kulp)

Mishnah, Avot 1:1

What contradicts it

2
  • Deut 4:2WLC· 7th–6th c. BCE (scholarly dating)

    Deuteronomy 4:2

    “You shall not add to the word which I command you, nor take from it.”

  • Deut 13:1WLC· 7th–6th c. BCE (scholarly dating)

    Deuteronomy 13:1 (12:32 in English Bibles)

    “All that I command you, you shall be careful to do; you shall not add to it nor take from it.”

How the tradition answers

The rabbinic reply: Scripture itself commands to act by the word of the judges and teachers (Deut 17:8–11). According to Maimonides the ban on “adding” is broken only by one who presents an ordinance of the sages as a commandment of the Torah itself; a fence declared as the sages' decree is not an addition (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Rebels 2:9).

Note

The chief Karaite objection to the Mishnah and Talmud.
The sages may enact new ordinances and “make a fence around the Torah”; the tradition… · Versemora