Skip to content

Contradiction · An older source

Quran 20:85–97

Whose text

Islam· as a whole

What is said

Quran 20:85–97: the golden calf at Sinai was made, and the people led astray, by al-Samiri; Harun (Aaron) tried to restrain them (20:90).

Where it is said

What contradicts it

3
  • Exod 32:1–6· 9th–6th c. BCE (dating debated)

    It is Aaron himself who casts the calf at the people's request (32:4, 32:21–24).

  • Hos 8:5–6· 8th c. BCE

    'Thy calf, O Samaria': the prophets link calf worship with the Northern Kingdom (cf. 1 Kgs 12:28–29).

  • 1 Kgs 16:24· 6th c. BCE (Deuteronomistic History)

    The city of Samaria was founded by King Omri c. 880 BCE; the 'Samaritans' as a people are named after it, centuries after the Exodus.

How the tradition answers

The commentators take al-Samiri as a personal name or nisba of a man among the Israelites (al-Tabari: from a people who venerated cattle), not as 'the Samaritan'; that the calf was not made by Aaron agrees with the doctrine of the prophets' sinlessness ('isma).

Note

Scholars (H. Speyer, 1931, and others) suggest an echo of Jewish polemic against the Samaritans and the northern calf cult.
Quran 20:85–97: the golden calf at Sinai was made, and the people led astray, by… · Versemora