Claims
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
19 claims
Verdict: A matter of interpretationProphecy9th–14th c.
“A prophet from among their brothers, like you” (Deut 18:15–18) is Muhammad: Israel's “brothers” are the descendants of Ishmael.
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationIdentityMedinan period (sura 3)
Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian but a ḥanīf surrendered to God (Quran 3:65–67).
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationProphecyRashi (11th c.); the Jewish reading known from the 3rd c.
The Suffering Servant of Isa 52:13–53:12 is the people of Israel, not the Messiah Jesus.
Rabbinic JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1168 (Commentary on the Mishnah)
Christians are idolaters (ʿovdei ʿavodah zarah), so the laws on idolatry apply to them (Maimonides).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: A matter of interpretationProphecyc. 80–90 (Gospel of Matthew)
“Behold, a virgin shall conceive and bear a son” (Isa 7:14) is a prophecy of Jesus' birth from a virgin (Matt 1:22–23).
The Early ChurchaboutJudaism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1537–1646
The Pope of Rome is the Antichrist, the “man of sin” (2 Thess 2).
ProtestantismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim2018
The Kyiv Metropolis has belonged to the Moscow Patriarchate since 1686, so the OCU's autocephaly is uncanonical.
Russian Orthodox ChurchaboutOrthodox Church of Ukraine
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim8th–10th c.
At Ghadir Khumm the Prophet appointed Ali as his successor.
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine10th–12th c.
The Mishnah and Talmud are human additions to the Torah, which the Torah itself forbids (Deut 4:2).
Karaite JudaismaboutRabbinic Judaism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim2nd–1st c. BCE
The high priest in Jerusalem is the “Wicked Priest”, and the festivals are kept there on the wrong days.
Essenes and the Qumran communityaboutSecond Temple Judaism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1870 (Pastor Aeternus; the dispute since the 5th–11th c.)
Christ gave the apostle Peter, and through him the bishops of Rome as his successors, a primacy of jurisdiction over the whole Church…
CatholicismaboutEastern Orthodoxy
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1739
The Calvinist doctrine of predestination makes God the author of sin: if God from eternity ordained all that comes to pass, choosing some…
MethodismaboutReformed Christianity (Calvinism)
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine2018
The Patriarchate of Constantinople has arrogated to itself the right to hear appeals from the whole Church and to grant autocephaly on its…
Russian Orthodox ChurchaboutEastern Orthodoxy
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1896–1897
Anglican ordinations are “absolutely null and utterly void” through defect of form (the Edwardine Ordinal of 1550/1552 does not express the…
CatholicismaboutAnglicanism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim20th c. (the dispute since early Islam)
The Sunnis' own collections testify that many Companions “turned back on their heels” after the Prophet's death: in the hadith of the Basin…
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine18th c.
Visiting saints' tombs for their intercession, calling on the dead for help (istighatha) and building domes over graves is polytheism…
Wahhabism and SalafismaboutSufism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1974 (the dispute since 1891)
“Seal of the prophets” (Quran 33:40) means there will be no prophet of any kind after Muhammad; Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, by declaring himself a…
Sunni IslamaboutAhmadiyya
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine2nd c.
God's covenant with Israel passed to the Church: the Jews lost it by rejecting Christ (and already at Sinai, when the tablets were broken)…
The Early ChurchaboutJudaism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine9th c.
The God of the Jewish scripture is neither omniscient nor good: he asked Adam “where art thou?” not knowing where he was, himself repented…
The Zoroastrian communityaboutJudaism